So far, no one has written a comprehensive theological argument proving that Pope Francis has taught or committed heresy. Here is what would be needed to be proven by a theological argument: 1. Prove, in contradiction to many magisterial teachings, … Continue reading
Pope Francis on God’s Will and the Diversity of Religions
Gallery
Heresy or Not? Pope Francis has been accused of heresy for his alleged teaching on the will of God and the plurality of religions. There are many different religions in the world. Certainly, God permits this situation, just as He … Continue reading
In Defense of Pope Honorius
Gallery
The Sixth Ecumenical Council (the third at Constantinople) was preparing to accuse him of heresy, many decades after his death. The Pope who reigned over the Council was Pope Saint Agatho. He wrote a letter to the Council trying to … Continue reading
7 Mistakes that Papal Critics Are Making
Gallery
1. The assumption that Popes Honorius I and John XXII committed or taught heresy. They never offer a theological argument to prove this accusation. They simply assume it. And that assumption establishes, without basis, half of their conclusion. For Pope … Continue reading
Accusing a Pope of Heresy: How We Got Here
Gallery
Conservative Catholics used to pride themselves on defending orthodoxy and believing the teachings of the Magisterium, especially the Pope. Liberal Catholics were sharply criticized by conservatives for allegedly being heterodox and unfaithful to magisterial teaching, especially papal teachings. When a … Continue reading
Summary of “The Indefectibility of the Roman Pontiff”
Gallery
This post is a summary of my book: The Indefectibility of the Roman Pontiff Which Popes Are Valid? The three conditions for a valid papacy are: 1. valid election; 2. free acceptance of the office; 3. ordination to the episcopal … Continue reading
April Newsletter Topics
Gallery
Topics for April Newsletter: 1. The Meaning of the Notre Dame de Paris Fire 2. Momentous Events in May of 2019 3. Papal Immunity from Error and a Never Failing Faith 4. How To Disagree with the Pope Faithfully and … Continue reading
What Does Michael Voris believe on Salvation?
Gallery
Maybe he doesn’t know what he believes. Maybe he’s ashamed to admit what he believes. Moreover, Mr. Voris couldn’t write a theological argument to support his position on salvation theology, or any other topic for that matter, if his job … Continue reading
The Council of Trent corrected an error by Aquinas on Transubstantiation
Gallery
The dogma of transubstantiation was infallibly defined by the Council of Trent: “The most holy Eucharist has indeed this in common with the rest of the sacraments, that it is a symbol of a sacred thing, and is a visible … Continue reading
Michael Voris – part 4 – Public Formal Schism
Gallery
This is part four of a four-article series. Read the previous three parts here: Part one, Part two, and Part three. Canon Law 751: “Can. 751 Heresy is the obstinate denial or obstinate doubt after the reception of baptism of … Continue reading
The Roman Pontiff: Immunity from Grave Error and Never-failing Faith
Gallery
In chronological order: St. Cyprian, 3rd century: “Where Peter is, there is the Church”, repeated by St. Ambrose and St. Boniface. Confirmed by Pope Benedict XV in the Encyclical In Hac Tanta. St. Cyprian: “If someone does not hold fast … Continue reading
Bishop Athanasisus Schneider: teacher of heresy
Gallery
Over at OnePeterFive.com: Bishop Athanasisus Schneider: On the Question of a Heretical Pope. 1. First, Pope Honorius I was never condemned by any Ecumenical Council for heresy. He was anathemized for having failed to do enough to stop the spread … Continue reading
